Climate change is accelerating the misinformation war and eroding social cohesion

Climate change is accelerating the misinformation war and eroding social cohesion
Getty Images/BeyondImages

No-one needs reminding that we live in an increasingly hostile environment; polarisation of views, geopolitical tensions, declining trust, inflammatory rhetoric, cyber bullying, assaults, riots and massacres. All contribute to a breakdown of social cohesion. 

As global temperature rises, pressures on communities will increase, creating an accelerant for hostile conditions with breakdown in social cohesion making it more difficult to address the causes of a warming planet and deal with the consequences.

If we look at adapting to the impact of rising temperature through the lens of social cohesion, it is clear how change is undertaken is as important as what changes we need to make to build community resilience. 

This stresses the importance of trust-building, community empowerment and power-sharing. We cannot rely on rational technocratic responses alone.

Rising tension, bad actors and bullying

AFP Commissioner Krissy Barrett described the threat environment, after the recent horrific attack on Helen Haines in Wangaratta, as “febrile”. Synonyms include hectic, agitated and frenetic.

ASIO reports that “personal grievance, intolerance and anti-authority beliefs are growing, amplified by social media and the normalisation of inflammatory rhetoric, violent language and violent acts.”

The former Director General of the Office of National Intelligence says geopolitics is operating in a grey zone between war and peace, creating new battlefields. Cyber attacks, political interference and disinformation are now routine, and foreign actors “seek to undermine our resilience and ultimately to break our resolve.”

Earlier this year, I worked with a group of Victorian councillors who highlighted the pressure public officials face working to promote climate action and the forces working against them.

This is particularly evident in regional areas. Hostile efforts aim to eliminate all council climate policies. In Northeast Victoria, two major councils have cancelled climate policies and commitments and resigned from the regional Goulburn Murray Climate Alliance.

Earlier this year, the Municipal Association of Victoria (MAV) documented disinformation and harassment of councillors who face “organised campaigns to undermine the legitimacy and authority of councils” including “those who use confrontational tactics to slow or undermine council processes.”

The report noted that councillors have responded through self-censoring, restricting social media presence, restricting physical attendance at public events and withdrawing from discussion of divisive topics. 

None of this is good for democracy, our ability to respond to extreme events such as fires and floods, or make transformational adjustments in response to a changing climate.

Misinformation and declining trust and safety

Misinformation is contributing to declining trust in science and impacting disaster preparedness with consequences for public safety, The Centre of Excellence for the Weather of the 21st Century told a recent Senate inquiry.

The Department of Home Affairs reports that false information – amplified by social media – can destabilise relationships between people and governments; “false information has fuelled conspiracy theories about the government's response to fires and floods ….”.

A Senate committee noted that mis- and disinformation apparently generated by bots and trolls was circulating on social media during the Black Summer bushfires of 2019-2020; “A study of 315 accounts using #ArsonEmergency revealed that a third were suspected to be bot or troll accounts.”

A Victorian Parliamentary Inquiry into January 2026 bushfires found power and cellular outages meant that communities desperately seeking information through various channels had the potential to be led to misinformation. Locals suspect that the bots and trolls were again active.

Climate is just one issue threatening social cohesion. It has been described in the security context as a “threat multiplier”; an accelerant to the underlying conditions that are already testing social cohesion such as cost of living.

Cost of living and social cohesion

Food costs have long been associated with social upheaval. 

Think of the flour wars that preceded the French revolution, bread riots and the Russian revolution or bread riots that preceded the Arab Spring.

It is not just bread. One measure uses a basket of commodities, the FAO Food Index, to track and predict social uprisings. Rudolfson and Smith argue that it is not just food but essential commodities; read ‘Cost of living’.

While the Municipal Association of Victoria has recognised the problem of threats and intimidation, we need to do more than educate and engage. 

Mark Duckworth and colleagues point out that lack of trust goes both ways. Communities don’t trust the government and governments don’t trust communities.

Public and private decisionmakers need to look at our own practices – can we democratise decision-making, rebuild trust by sharing power and allowing communities to make meaningful decisions? Can federal and state agencies act as service centres supporting community governance rather than hierarchies deciding what is best?

In his analysis of failing liberal democracy in the United States (but applicable elsewhere), What Happened to Liberal Democracy, Nobel Laureate Daron Acemoglu, sees community self-governance as one of four pillars for saving liberal democracy.

Fellows of the National Academy of Public Administration in the US arrived at a similar conclusion about community governance in their recent paper on transforming government. 

They also argue our work needs to focus on delivering societal outcomes rather than self-serving project outcomes.

All of this is consistent with what we know about adaptation governance; that it needs to be inclusive and bottom-up. None of this is easy. Communities won’t always arrive at the best decision but then, neither do experts in government and politicians. 

In the current threat environment, those working on climate issues need to consider the precarious condition of many communities, particularly in regional and remote areas, where relative isolation can make people vulnerable to both misinformation and climate impacts. 

Climate mitigation and adaptation must be undertaken in a way that contributes to social cohesion, not the opposite.

Read More

Republish

You may republish this article online or in print under our Creative Commons licence. You may not edit or shorten the text, you must attribute the article to MONASH OPINION & ANALYSIS, and you must include the author's name in your republication.

If you have any questions, please email media@monash.edu

Republishing Guidelines

https://lens.monash.edu/republishing-guidelines

Title

Climate change is accelerating the misinformation war and eroding social cohesion

Content