Last month, Australia appeared before the UN Committee on the Rights of the Child in Geneva for a five-year assessment of the government’s progress in protecting the rights of children. The hearing included submissions from the Australian government, the Australian Human Rights Commission and civil society organisations on everything from youth justice issues to children’s health and wellbeing.
Among those who spoke at the hearing was 12-year-old Dujuan Hoosan from Arrernte and Garrwa country in central Australia, who called on the Australian government to stop imprisoning 10-year-olds, support Aboriginal-led education programs, and respect the culture and rights of all children in Australia.
"I came here to speak with you because the Australian government is not listening. Adults never listen to kids like me. But we have important things to say."
He is believed to be the youngest person to address the UN Human Rights Council.
On Friday, the UN committee handed down its report – and it paints a gloomy picture.
The committee was extremely critical of the Australian government on a range of issues. These included the high numbers of children in care and the criminal justice system, the continued forced sterilisation of children with disabilities, the government’s treatment of refugee and asylum-seeking children, and the lack of meaningful opportunities for children to participate in decision-making on policies that affect their lives.
Many of the recommendations go to the heart of the ingrained political, cultural and legal inferiority of children in Australia.
Children and the criminal justice system
The Australian government played a major role in the drafting and passage of the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child nearly 30 years ago, and was among its first signatories. The convention is one of the most ratified human rights treaties in history. It plays an important role in defining and upholding the rights of children.
Despite this, Australia still does not have a national strategy to ensure the implementation of appropriate protections of children’s rights.
The youth justice system in Australia, for example, has been described for some time as being in crisis.
In 2017, the Royal Commission into the Protection and Detention of Children in the Northern Territory shone a light onto some of the most serious violations in Australia’s youth justice system. It found that over the past decade, children in the Northern Territory were frequently mistreated, abused, humiliated and left alone for long periods. The local government has done little to address the issues since then.
Queensland’s youth justice system is now under scrutiny, after media reports earlier this year found that children as young as 10 were being housed in adult watch houses.
Nationally, media reports and official statistics show the rising numbers of children being remanded in prison rather than being granted bail. This is contrary to international guidelines, that say that prison should only be used as a “last resort”.
The UN committee report made a number of major recommendations on criminal justice issues, including urging the Australian government:
to immediately raise the minimum age of criminal responsibility from 10 to an internationally acceptable age of 14
to immediately implement the 2018 recommendations of the Australian Law Reform Commission to reduce the high rates of Indigenous children who are imprisoned
to prohibit the use of isolation and force against children in detention, including the use of restraints, and immediately investigate all cases of abuse and mistreatment of children in detention
to urge the Northern Territory and Western Australia to review and repeal mandatory minimum sentences for children.
The committee also urged Australia to explicitly prohibit corporal punishment of children in all settings, including homes, schools, detention centres and alternative care. It also called for laws in states and territories that permit “reasonable chastisement” to be repealed.
These laws currently allow adults to physically discipline children as long as it is “reasonable” in the circumstances. As campaigners against the practice rightly argue, “reasonable” is a vague term and open to interpretation. The UN committee wants it banned, as has recently taken place in Scotland.
Mental health and suicide
The committee also said it was “seriously concerned” that the number of Australian children with mental health problems was on the rise. This is particularly so for children in Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander communities or alternative care, those who are experiencing homelessness, living in rural and remote areas or asylum-seekers, those from culturally diverse backgrounds, and LGBTI children.
The report noted that "almost one in seven children were assessed with mental health problems, with suicide being the leading cause of death for those aged 15-24".
Among its recommendations to the government were:
prioritising mental health service delivery to children in vulnerable situations, such as those groups listed above
strengthening measures to ensure the side effects of certain drugs for ADHD are fully communicated to parents/guardians and children and that they are prescribed “as a measure of last resort”
continuing to provide children with education on sexual and reproductive health as part of the mandatory school curriculum.
Political attitudes toward children
Finally, the committee also addressed the ways in which Australian politicians responded to children who took part in recent climate strikes.
The committee emphasised that the effects of climate change have an undeniable impact on children’s rights, and expressed “its concern and disappointment” that the children’s climate change protests "received a strongly worded negative response from those in authority, which demonstrates disrespect for their right to express their views on this important issue".
Time for change
None of these changes will happen without political will. Civil society, human rights groups and state children’s commissioners have crucial roles to play in continuing to advocate on behalf of children and speak up when they are being mistreated and their rights are being infringed.
The committee’s report card is not a badge of honour, and it puts Australia on a list of countries that have the necessary resources to support their next generation, but are failing to do so.
To celebrate 30 years of the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child, Monash University’s School of Social Sciences will be hosting a panel discussion with leading advocates, academics and community members on 20 November, aimed at advancing the rights of children in the criminal justice system. Event details here.
This article was co-authored with Noam Peleg, a UNSW senior lecturer, and was originally published on The Conversation.
To receive a fortnightly email wrap up of stories from Lens.